Grease the slow cooker. Coat the inside of a 4- to 6-quart slow cooker with butter or nonstick spray. This prevents the pasta from sticking and helps the cheese sauce stay silky.
Add the base ingredients. Add the uncooked elbow macaroni, evaporated milk, whole milk, butter pieces, salt, pepper, mustard powder, and paprika to the slow cooker. Stir until the pasta is coated and submerged.
Cook low and slow. Cover and cook on LOW for 2 to 2 1/2 hours, stirring once after the first hour. The pasta should be tender and the milk mostly absorbed, but check from the 2-hour mark — every slow cooker is a little different.
Stir in the cheeses. Add the shredded cheddar, Monterey Jack, and cream cheese cubes. Stir until completely melted and the sauce is thick and creamy, about 2 minutes.
Rest and thicken. Let the mac and cheese rest with the lid on for 10 minutes. The sauce will thicken to the perfect spoon-coating consistency.
Serve. Stir once more, taste and adjust salt, then serve hot with a sprinkle of paprika and chives if you like.